Current:Home > MarketsIn Battle to Ban Energy-Saving Light Bulbs, GOP Defends ‘Personal Liberty’-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
In Battle to Ban Energy-Saving Light Bulbs, GOP Defends ‘Personal Liberty’
View Date:2024-12-25 00:15:10
Republicans in Congress are pressing for a vote on Monday on one of the stranger elements of their environmental agenda — a ban on the adoption of energy-efficient light bulbs. A bill championed by presidential contender Michele Bachmann and others would repeal a law phasing out incandescent bulbs from 2012.
According to some reports, the Republican leadership in the House of Representatives was pressing to introduce the bill under rules that would limit debate, but also require a two-thirds vote to pass. Energy-saving bulbs were seen as an entirely harmless innovation — even by the same Republicans who now oppose them — when the lighting efficiency measure was signed into law by the then president, George W Bush, as part of a broader energy package.
The 2007 law would have started phasing out old-fashioned 100-watt bulbs starting in January 2012, with an aim of making light bulbs more than 25 percent efficient. Incandescent bulbs emit most of the energy they consume as heat.
Fred Upton, now the chair of the energy and commerce committee, supported the law — a vote which has come back to haunt him in a more conservative Congress. The initiative also had the support of lighting manufacturers.
But the new breed of Tea party conservatives, encouraged by chat show hosts like Rush Limbaugh, have cast the promotion of the more efficient LED and CFL lights as a shining example of needless government interference.
They also argue that the bulbs cost more than the old-fashioned variety and are health hazards, because they contain mercury. But their most passionately voiced argument is freedom. Hanging on to the old-style bulbs is really about personal liberty, they say.
Republicans in the Texas, Pennsylvania, and South Carolina state legislatures are also working on measures to keep burning incandescent bulbs. “This is about more than just energy consumption, it is about personal freedom,” said Joe Barton, the Texas Republican behind the new bill, said in a statement after last year’s mid-term election.
“Voters sent us a message in November that it is time for politicians and activists in Washington to stop interfering in their lives and manipulating the free market. The light bulb ban is the perfect symbol of that frustration. People don’t want Congress dictating what light fixtures they can use.”
However the energy secretary, Steven Chu, has argued that the 2007 law does not amount to a blanket ban on all incandescent bulbs. But it does require those bulbs to be more efficient.
“These standards do not ban incandescent bulbs,” Chu told a conference call with reporters. “You’re still going to be able to buy halogen incandescent bulbs. They’ll look exactly like the ones you’re used to. They can dim. They cut out instantly. They look and feel the same.”
The Natural Resources Defense Council also produced a study on Friday suggesting that the energy-saving bulbs would save the average American household $85 a year on their electricity bill. They would also eliminate the need for 30 large power plants, reporters were told.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Texas man accused of supporting ISIS charged in federal court
- Barbora Krejcikova beat Jasmine Paolini in thrilling women's Wimbledon final for second Grand Slam trophy
- Sarah Michelle Gellar Details Decades-Long Bond With Shannen Doherty After Her Death
- 2024 MLB draft tracker day 2: Every pick from rounds 3-10
- Opinion: NFL began season with no Black offensive coordinators, first time since the 1980s
- Second day of jury deliberations to start in Sen. Bob Menendez’s bribery trial
- Condos’ high-rising insurance premiums are a top issue in these legislative races
- Barbora Krejcikova beat Jasmine Paolini in thrilling women's Wimbledon final for second Grand Slam trophy
- My Chemical Romance will perform 'The Black Parade' in full during 2025 tour: See dates
- Magnitude 3.4 earthquake recorded outside of Chicago Monday morning
Ranking
- A Pipeline Runs Through It
- Aetna set to run North Carolina worker health care as Blue Cross will not appeal judge’s ruling
- Katy Perry Shares NSFW Confession on Orlando Bloom's Magic Stick
- A prison union’s big spending on Gavin Newsom: Is it an ‘800 pound gorilla’ or a threatened species?
- NFL Week 11 picks straight up and against spread: Will Bills hand Chiefs first loss of season?
- Panel recommends removing ex-chancellor from Wisconsin college faculty post for making porn videos
- Steven Stamkos on move: 'I never thought this day would come'
- Watch: Satellite video tracks Beryl's path tearing through the Atlantic, Caribbean and U.S.
Recommendation
-
'I heard it and felt it': Chemical facility explosion leaves 11 hospitalized in Louisville
-
Samsung announces Galaxy Z Fold6 and Z Flip6. Is it time to get a foldable smartphone?
-
Social media influencers tell you to buy, buy, buy. Stop listening to them.
-
When does EA Sports College Football 25 come out? Some will get to play on Monday.
-
Food prices worried most voters, but Trump’s plans likely won’t lower their grocery bills
-
Sparks Fly in Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Double Date Photo With Brittany and Patrick Mahomes
-
Trump shot at rally in failed assassination attempt. Here's everything we know so far.
-
Israeli attack on southern Gaza Strip leaves at least 90 dead, the Health Ministry in Gaza says